6 reasons why a downturn in steel won’t be as bad as in the past
The tumult in financial markets will spill over into the ‘real’ economy in a number of ways not least of course in slowing economic growth on regional and global levels. Slower economic growth means less steel consumption and production so it’s worthwhile, if a little sobering, to contemplate just how hard steel might be hit.
There have been three periods of significant global steel production decline in the last 50 years. The first covers the period of 1974-75, the second from 1979 to 1982 and the third 1989 to 1992. The respective cumulative declines in production were 9%, 14% and 8% respectively.
If the current slowdown in the industry were to be as deep as the deepest of the declines (14%) we would see steel production off some 190MT from 2008 levels. But if we take the average percentage of the three declines for each region we get an aggregate global steel production decline of just 5% or 70MT. A drop of 190MT would imply global capacity utilization in the mid-70%’s; a drop of 70MT would imply a utilization rate in the low 80% range.
But while it’s necessary to look at worst case scenarios there’s reason to believe that things won’t be as bad in the next couple of years as these prior declines might suggest. The current steel industry environment enjoys a number of signficant differences when compared to those of 20 and 30 years ago.
- First, global economic growth in each of those earlier periods was between 1% and 2%. The October GDP forecast from the IMF shows global growth dipping to about 3% in 2009 but sustaining growth at about 4% over the three year period through 2011.
- Second, in those earlier periods, outside of Korea there were few large rapidly industrializing economies. In fact, the global economic order was changing dramatically. The Eastern Bloc collapse in the third period of decline marked the end of centrally planned economies and the obliteration of a large portion of industrial demand. In contrast today many of the major steel producing regions of the world are industrializing and, even if very slowly in some cases, liberalizing with expectations of continued robust growth for some time. In the examples mentioned above China and India grow at -1% in the worst case scenario and 0% in the ‘average’ decline scenario. The last World Steel Association (IISI) short term forecast (from April) showed Asia & Oceania growing at 8% p.a. in apparent steel use. Even if this rate is halved in the revised forecast to 4%, then our Far East production growth would amount to 30MT reclaiming in one year almost half the ‘average’ scenario decline of 5% . Read the rest of this entry »



